Dutch Oven Pot Roast

2020 Best Dutch Oven Pot Roast

If you are new to Dutch oven cooking or you know that you will not be using it frequently, it makes little sense to invest in a very expensive one. The Lodge cast iron Dutch oven is perfect for you and at a price that won’t make your eyes water.

With thousands of positive reviews online, we are not alone at marveling at its performance and price.

I have no hesitation in recommending the Lodge Dutch oven.

Lodge Color 6-Quart Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven

  • One Lodge 6 Quart Red Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven
  • Features a stainless steel knob and loop handles for great control
  • Smooth glass surface won’t react to ingredients
  • Unparalleled heat retention and even heating
  • Use to marinate, refrigerate, cook, and serve
  • Great for induction cooktops

I had a low expectation about the Lodge before I began using it. This was based entirely on the price…it was the cheapest Dutch oven I was testing…the cheapest by a long way. How could this possibly compete with the higher priced ones. Surely it couldn’t…there must be a reason why some are 6 times more expensive?

I was wrong. This is a fantastic Dutch oven. No if’s…no buts.

Let’s talk about the construction as I’m sure you will be wondering how something so cheap fares so well against the more expensive competitors.

You have nothing to worry about, it is strong, heavy, robust and complete with a nice finish. The shape bows out slightly in the middle which means that food will not get stuck in the crevices. This does reduce the surface area of the base though so if you are searing large cuts of meat, it is a consideration.

The lid fits as well as you would expect and comes with a metal knob. Obviously, this means it gets hot in the oven but it’s not a deal breaker. The handles were large and easy to move wearing oven gloves.

The interior is stone colored and will stain depending on what you cook. Again, this is the same for most enamel Dutch ovens and nothing really to be concerned about. You can clean them almost back to new using various techniques.

Let’s get to the cooking. The oven heated quickly and consistently, the searing and browning of the meat was done beautifully. Exactly the same as a much more expensive version. The end result was a beautiful beef stew that was thick and succulent.

Product Highlights
Price Fantastic cooking results Bigger handles than the rest we tested Curved shape means food does not get stuck in corners Shorter sides and wider means better searing performance Easy to clean Lifetime warranty
Product information
Size:6 Quart | Color:Red
Product Dimensions 14 x 7 x 12 inches
Item Weight 14.88 pounds
Department Unisex-adult
Manufacturer Lodge

Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Enameled Cast Iron 5-Quart

  • Porcelain enameled exterior both durable finish land rich in colors complements any kitchen dcor. Cast iron contraction retains heat well. The porcelain enameled interior is perfect for cooking: surfaces do not impact flavors or absorb odors.
  • Wide cast iron handles provide a comfortable and secure grip. Easy transport for serving. Oven safe knob for a durable grip and endless cooking options. Stovetop, oven and broiler safe. Induction stovetop compatible.
  • Cast Iron construction provides superior heat retention and even heat distribution.
  • Strong, durable finish in rich colors complements any kitchen dcor. Perfect for cooking, serving and entertaining.
  • Convenient maintenance and easy cleanup and dishwasher safe
  • Porcelain enameled exterior both durable finish land rich in colors complements any kitchen décor. Cast iron contraction retains heat well. The porcelain enameled interior is perfect for cooking: surfaces do not impact flavors or absorb odors.
  • Wide cast iron handles provide a comfortable and secure grip. Easy transport for serving. Oven safe knob for a durable grip and endless cooking options. Stovetop, oven and broiler safe. Induction stovetop compatible.

Out of all the Dutch ovens we tested, the Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Enameled Cast Iron 5-Quart came out joint top alongside the Lodge version on sheer taste alone. The Beef stew we made was an absolute dream…tender, thick and tasty. Wonderful.

The build quality was good, everything was done well. I liked the shape too, no creases for the food to stick in. The lid fitted very well too. The handle was a decent size so posed no problems with oven gloves.

Unfortunately, as good as the food was, it didn’t quite merit first place. The simmering was inconsistent which meant that we had to stir it. Its not a deal breaker but not an ideal for a Dutch oven.

The other issue I found was the dulling of the enamel color in the dishwasher. They are dishwasher proof according to the manufacturer. However, its clear that this is not recommended. If you want to keep the luster, hand wash only. The exposed iron on the rim is something to keep an eye on, make sure it is dried properly to avoid rust.

Product Highlights

Beautiful construction Tight fitting lid Not as heavy as some others Heat proof lid handle Great cooking performance Premium brand that holds value Lifetime warranty

Product information
Size:5 Qt Covered Casserole | Color:Enameled Cardinal Red
Product Dimensions 11.6 x 11.6 x 6.22 inches
Item Weight 1 pounds
Manufacturer Cuisinart

Staub Round Cocotte

  • Made in France
  • Heavy weight, tight-fitting lid retains moisture, spikes on the lid create a rain-forest effect evenly returning juices back onto food
  • Oven safe up to 900F/482C without lid, Lids are oven safe up to 500F/260C
  • Nickel steel knob
  • Smooth enamel bottom works on all stovetops, including gas, electric, glass, ceramic, induction, and halogen
  • Unique, interior matte texture results in exceptional browning
  • Dishwasher safe, hand wash recommended

This is the first time I have cooked with a Staub and I wasn’t disappointed. The price was…it was expensive to match the Le Creuset. However, it didn’t disappoint.

The meat browned evenly and nicely, although it involved some guesswork as it was difficult to judge against the black interior. As expected, the stew came out fantastically well and it lost very little moisture.

One of the main selling points by Staub is the self-basting lid. If it worked then great but I can’t say that it made any difference to this dish. Obviously for roasting chicken it may make a real difference but I will wait and see.

I have to say that this was my favorite Dutch oven when it came to style. It is wonderful to look at. The shiny exterior with the black interior.

Staub say their enamel coating is free from cadmium and lead which delivers better heat resistance. It is also enameled on the exterior base which means you can use this safely on glass stoves. On the inside, it is black so difficult to see what is going on. The inside contains traces of quartz which is said to deliver additional heat resistance and a rougher surface. This should mean that it browns better than a smooth surface.

Overall though, it performed marginally better than the Le Creuset but for the same reason, I could not recommend it. It’s too expensive for what it does.

Product Highlights
Great design with premium construction Tight fitting lid Even heat distribution Great cooking performance Premium brand that holds value Lifetime warranty
Product information
Size:5.5 quart | Color:Basil
Product Dimensions 15 x 11.1 x 5.9 inches
Item Weight 12.55 pounds
Manufacturer Staub

Tramontina 6.5-Quart Covered Round Dutch Oven

  • Great price
  • Decent cooking performance
  • Safe to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Coated with PFOA and PTFE-free porcelain enamel
  • Warranty in line with the market

Everything was good about the Tramontina. It browned evenly and cooked well. Everything was good. It just wasn’t outstanding at anything in particular.

When compared to the Lodge where it competes in price, it just lacked a little in comparison. For that reason, I would go with the Lodge version. That is not to say that this isn’t a decent Dutch oven. It is.

Construction wise, it was decently built and reassuringly heavy. It browned, as they all did, nicely. The beef was tender and the sauce thicker than it should be. This due to the higher moisture loss as a result of the lid not being as tight.

What was odd about this was the dimensions. This was much taller than the rest with a lower internal surface area. This made browning more difficult and it would pose an issue with larger cuts of meat.

Product Highlights
I wanted to make sure I really got a flavor of their performance. The real selling point of a Dutch oven is the way you can move it from stove-top to oven.
Product information
Package Dimensions 15.9 x 13.1 x 8.2 inches
Item Weight 16.27 pounds
Manufacturer Tramontina

Anolon Vesta 5-Quart Round Covered Cast Iron Casserole

  • Anolon Vesta cookware fuses superior heating with singular stove-to-oven-table style and performance for creative cast iron cooking
  • Dutch oven features stain-resistant black matte enamel interior for beautiful cooking, searing and browning with easy cleaning
  • Gorgeous porcelain enamel exterior in a rich gourmet-inspired color
  • The covered casserole’s self-basting lid features a distinctive stainless steel handle, and elegant side handles provide ample room for potholder grip
  • Broiler safe, this induction-suitable covered round casserole is suitable for all stovetops

This durable, cute cast iron cookware from Anolon Vesta will take you to new level of culinary experience and taste. Anolon Vesta cast iron casserole is a casserole known for its great heat retention and absorption with great stovetop-to-table style and durability. It is best suited for all cook tops, such as induction. It is an elegant Dutch oven to prep your favorite potato stews or chicken.

Product Highlights
Easy to clean, gorgeous porcelain enamel finish on exterior Stain-resistant black matt finish on interior Fuses great heating
Product information
Color:Umber | Size:5-Quart
Product Dimensions 13.5 x 13.1 x 6.9 inches
Item Weight 9.9 pounds
Manufacturer Anolon

Camp Chef DO-14 Pre-Seasoned 12-quart Deluxe 14” Dutch Oven

  • Grand Canyon National Park Commemorative Edition
  • True Seasoned Finish cast iron Dutch oven with Built-in thermometer notch
  • Lid with legs can be used as a skillet/griddle
  • Dutch Oven Lid Lifter INCLUDED – lifts lid and bail (Model 400035) and Includes Dutch Oven starter booklet with seasoning tips
  • Total Volume: 11 7/8 Qt

Make your favorite and flavorful meals with Camp Chef DO-14 Pre-Seasoned Dutch oven. Cook your favorite fruit cobbler and roasted meats. All you need to turn lid off to cook your delicious bacon, eggs, or pancakes and replace lid and cook the potatoes you love for your next flavorful meal.

Product Highlights
Comes with easy loop handle Use legs as griddle/skillet on the lid Easy to cook your favorite dishes
Product information
Product Dimensions 15.16 x 15.16 x 7.75 inches
Item Weight 24.9 pounds
Department Unisex-adult
Manufacturer Camp Chef

Le Creuset 5 ½ quart Signature Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven

  • 45% larger handles that provide a sure grip, even with oven mitts. Heat Source-Ceramic Hob, Electric Hob, Gas Hob, Grill, Oven safe, Induction hob
  • The superior heat distribution and retention of le creuset enameled cast iron
  • An advanced sand-colored interior enamel with even more resistance to wear
  • A larger composite knob that withstands temperatures up to 500ºF
  • Colorful, long-lasting exterior enamel that resists chipping and cracking
  • 5-1/2-quart round-shaped French oven made of enameled cast iron
  • Cast-iron loop side handles; black, phenolic, stay-cool lid knob

This Dutch oven from Le Creuset is designed to improve the cooking in your kitchen as it distributes heat evenly and locks in proper moisture level. The handles are designed ergonomically and come with world-class interior enamel which is easy to clean and resists chipping. It blends with recent innovations well.

The best part of this Dutch oven is that it has 45% larger handles for smooth grip. It uses sand colored enamel to resist chipping and wear

Product Highlights
Resists heat around 500 deg. F Best used on gas, electric, and ceramic cooktops Made of enamel coated cast iron
Product information
Color:Cherry | Size:5.5 qt
Product Dimensions 10 x 10.75 x 4 inches
Item Weight 12.7 pounds
Department Unisex
Manufacturer Le Creuset of America

Bruntmor 6.5-inch Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven Casserole Dish

  • Enameled solid cast-iron offers superior and even heat retention while vibrant porcelain-enamel exterior offers contemporary styling
  • Foods will not react with the easy-to-clean, PFOA- and PTFE-free porcelain enamel cooking surface
  • Self-basting condensation ridges on lid uniformly collect and direct vapors onto food, producing moist and savory dishes
  • Secure fitted lid with stainless steel knob helps keep heat in
  • Enameled live green exterior color and cream colored interior will complement any kitchen décor, easy to clean and maintain its great looks

Bruntmor 6.5-inch Enameled Cast Iron is the fiery red enameled cast iron Dutch oven is the perfect cookware for your kitchen and campfire. It comes with 6.5 quart of capacity and it will be delightful and entertaining for your guests and family with a lot of food. It retains heat well band saves energy while cooking with lower temperature. You can cook from bread to stews. It is heavy duty and top quality gift for any camper, newlyweds and home cook.

lazing
Enamel frits are independently developed and produced. The glaze developed by the factory’s company is in full compliance with food safety requirements. Over ninety-percent of the orders made to the factory are machine made. Benefits include; strong tightness, good molding, efficient enamel coating an secure delivery.

Blasting
The dutch ovens are polished, producing a flat casting surface and then subsequently blasted to remove impurities. They are then sprayed three times to glaze the top and bottom.

Inspection
We perform thermal shock tests by heating with a specialized machine, preventing cracks, grains and chipping. The steel balls test is performed by dropping a ball from about three feet high on to the product. Is there is no damage, the test is considered successful. Acid tests also check for corrosion in the product.

Product Highlights
Made of solid, high quality cast iron Red enamel durable nonstick coating Product resists heat around 400 deg. F Works on gas, ceramic, and electric cooktops Lid locks moisture really very well
Product information
Color:Olive Green
Product Dimensions 10 x 5 x 5 inches
Item Weight 16.53 pounds
Manufacturer Bruntmor

 Dutch Oven Cleaning Instructions 

-> Let the hot pan to cool down to before you wash and to clean the Dutch oven which has enamel coating. Don’t clean it in extremely cold water because enamel coating might be affected due to thermal shock.

-> If your Dutch oven has food leftovers stuck in it, simply soak it in warm water for up to 15 to 20 minutes to remove debris.

-> Let your Dutch oven to dry and keep away from steam to avoid the build-up of moisture.

-> Check knobs and handles regularly as you need to tighten them over time.

-> It is also important to replace knobs over time as they wear out.

 Steps to Season Dutch oven  –

  • First of all, preheat the cookware to 425 deg. F
  • Apply olive oil all around the cast iron pot with a clan rag
  • Leave the pot on the oven for one hour until its smoking.
  • Remove it from the oven and let it sit in the air to cool down
  • Repeat the above steps for two times more

 

Conclusion

Marinate, bake, fry, and boil almost any food with this Dutch oven. It is best to use over the stove, put it in the oven or use as outdoor cook, or in the grill.  If you are brand conscious, we recommend you to go with Calphalon or Le Creusets. These are the best quality ovens. We hope, you’ve liked the above buyers’ guide and best Dutch oven reviews.

Logo
Login/Register access is temporary disabled